Les Hernieux et la Bicyclette
Cite this book
Citation
A. Mignon. Les Hernieux et la Bicyclette. 1899. cyclearchive.com, https://cyclearchive.com/books/les-hernieux-et-la-bicyclette-1899/
Page numbers are pages of the PDF, which can differ from the numbers printed on the page.
Contents
- Explains the thesis was prompted by Lucas-Championnière's 1899 communication to the Academy of Medicine on curing hernias through cycling, and by the author's own encounters with hernia sufferers who cycled without ill effects; states the study will focus mainly on inguinal hernias.
- Reviews the mixed medical verdict on cycling and hernias, Professor Berger's later-withdrawn caution about falls, and British authorities (Bury, Hillier, Cresswell, Cortis) who found no evidence cycling causes hernias, concluding that bans stem from fear of falls and a false analogy with horse riding.
- Surveys hernia classification (reducible, irreducible, strangulated) and causation theory, following Berger and Lucas-Championnière's view that obesity and weakened abdominal walls, not sudden effort, are the true cause, implying an exercise that reduces fat could improve rather than worsen a hernia.
- An 18-year-old office clerk with a simple inguinal hernia since age 12 stops needing his truss after three years of daily cycling; the hernia no longer protrudes even when coughing.
- A 34-year-old newspaper delivery cyclist riding 10-12 hours daily for ten years finds his pigeon-egg-sized inguinal hernia now reduces very easily, despite the heavy daily riding.
- A 40-year-old former racer's hernia, first noticed after a bicycle fall, shrank and improved under cycling and has stayed improved for four years since he stopped riding, though he now needs a truss to walk.
- A 56-year-old insurance clerk with a lifelong irreducible double inguinal hernia (epiplocele) shows no change at all from eight years of amateur cycling, cited as a negative control case.
- A 58-year-old man with large, irreducible double inguinal-scrotal hernias can cycle three hours a day without fatigue despite being exhausted by a short walk, riding a woman's-frame machine to clear the enlarged hernias.
- A well-known professional distance racer with an extremely large lifelong double scrotal hernia completes a punishing 24-hour road race without a truss and reports the hernia feels lighter while racing, though it worsens again once he switches from cycling to motoring.
- Dr Loir's Tunis case: a 36-year-old professional man's inguinal hernia, resistant to trusses and considered for surgery, comes under control after he switches to a low women's-frame bicycle ridden at a gentle pace, within a year it stops protruding even under a cough, and the inguinal canal narrows and firms.
- Dr Schoull's Tunis case: a hernia caused by violent exertion and worsened by chronic bronchitis resolves after three months of daily moderate 30-40km rides, with no further protrusion even on coughing.
- Dr Georges Petit's case: a young track cyclist's inguinal hernia, which seemed to vanish during years of racing, reappears eight months after he abandons cycling for motorcycling, cited as evidence favoring cycling specifically, not exercise or motoring in general.
- Proposes cycling's mechanism of benefit, smooth muscular effort without jolts, a seated posture eliminating the vertical shocks of walking and the jarring of horse riding, reduced abdominal fat, and better intestinal regularity, while ruling out fencing, apparatus gymnastics and motorcycling as unsuitable for hernia sufferers.
- Concludes nearly all hernia sufferers, regardless of age or hernia size, may cycle; the only real contraindication is severe local pain, for which a stationary home trainer is recommended until it subsides, and notes that hyper-sensitive patients who cannot tolerate a truss often manage well on a bicycle without one.
- Sets out practical rules: avoid falls and racing-speed effort, avoid steep climbs, prefer a low frame with the seat set well back behind the pedals (per Lucas-Championnière's recommendation to the Academy of Medicine), dismount gently rather than jumping off, avoid cobbled roads, and use judgment on whether to keep wearing a truss.
- States that of the nine case reports, only the two irreducible hernias showed no improvement; concludes cycling has never been shown to cause, worsen or aggravate a hernia, generally improves the sufferer's overall condition, and is the exercise of choice for hernia patients provided the stated rules are followed.